The Riddle Of The D-Day Footage

April 26, 2010 by Marc Milner


The beginning of the end of Nazi-occupied Europe began well before the May 1945 liberation of the Netherlands, when Allied forces stormed the shores of Normandy in June 1944. Thousands of lives were lost and thousands more shattered during the long and difficult battles that brought liberation to France, Belgium and the Netherlands over the next several months.

They were days filled with incredible moments of courage and sacrifice, many of which will remain untold and lost forever to time. Among the more well known and preserved D-Day moments, however, is one found on a grainy black and white film shot by Sergeant Bill Grant of the Canadian Army Film and Photo Unit (CAFPU). Dubbed the iconic footage of the greatest assault landing in history and lasting only two minutes and 10 seconds, the clip shows Canadian infantry disembarking from an assault craft at Bernières-sur-Mer on June 6, 1944.

According to James O’Regan’s splendid documentary history of the CAFPU, Shooters, this footage was the first seen by Eisenhower and Montgomery, Roosevelt and Churchill, and it remains the only actual film of the assault to survive.

Anyone who has ever seen a documentary on the Normandy landings has seen it, and many Canadians know it well. Don Cherry even featured the footage on Coaches Corner during the NHL playoff game on June 6, 2009. But Canadians have no idea who these men are and where the footage was shot. It is time they knew.

The footage shows men of the North Shore (New Brunswick) Regiment landing on Nan Red, the codename for one of the beaches in the Canadian assault area.

For Canadians, uncertainty over “who and where” stems from the knowledge that the footage was shot at Bernières-sur-Mer. As anyone who knows a little about the Canadian role in D-Day will tell you, the Queen’s Own Rifles of Canada, a Toronto unit, landed at Bernières. Western battalions of the 7th Canadian Brigade landed at Courseulles-sur-Mer, and it has been generally assumed that the North Shore (N.B.) Regt. landed at St. Aubin-sur-Mer on the eastern flank. Descriptions of their landing focus on the perils of the seawall, the gun position that caused so much trouble, which sits on the seawall in the heart of the village even today. There has also been the presence of Canadian and French commemorations of the assault on St. Aubin at the location of the gun position. Pilgrims naturally gravitate to the gun position and the memorial, and descriptions of the North Shore (N.B.) Regt. assault along that seawall in front of the village naturally follow—I know, because I did it many times.

But the North Shore (N.B.) Regt. did not land at St. Aubin-sur-Mer: they, too, landed at Bernières-sur-Mer. In fact, they landed in the little seaside community of La Rive Plage which was—and remains—part of the municipality of Bernières. The regiment’s assault came ashore on either side of an open stretch of beach, which is now a park, designed by D-Day planners as gap N-7. On June 6, 1944, the eastern side of N-7 was dominated by a waterfront chateau, protected on three sides by a large seawall. The chateau and its seawall were severely damaged during the assault. Since then, tide and time—and probably military engineers looking for material to build tracks through N-7 and the great storm of June 19-22, 1944—removed all trace. The area where the chateau and its seawall stood is now a broad expanse of beach, and it is where the village of St. Aubin—fittingly—conducts its annual D-Day memorial, because this is where the landing actually happened.

The North Shore (N.B.) Regt. landed on either side of gap N-7. B Company landed on the left, near the chateau, followed by D. The iconic film footage of D-Day shows the assault on the west side, which was led by A Company with C Company following in reserve.

The first to make a definitive connection between the film footage and the North Shore (N.B.) Regt. was British historian Tim Saunders. His book, Juno Beach, published as part of the Battleground Europe: Normandy series issued by Pen and Sword Books in the U.K. in 2004, identified houses in the footage that are still standing on the beach. His book includes a 2004 photograph of the small, rather square two-storey waterfront home that stands in the centre of most of Grant’s incredible footage. Other photos taken by Saunders and passed to this writer also show the elaborate timber-framed house with the attached garage that occasionally slips into the right-hand frame of the D-Day footage: it too, still stands. In 2006, I had a chance to confirm all this on site, and to confirm with survivors of the Royal Marine Commands, who came ashore behind the North Shore (N.B.) Regt., the location of the chateau and its seawall.

The presence of these two houses at La Rive Plage confirms that the footage of the Normandy invasion shows the North Shore (N.B.) Regt. landing on D-Day. But whether it is A or C company, it’s hard to say. Saunders says emphatically that the footage is of A Company. Fred Moar of Miramichi, N.B., the last surviving North Shore (N.B.) Regt. officer who landed on D-Day and a young platoon commander at the time, agrees. He reviewed the footage in 2006 and identified the soldier who turns his face in profile to the camera (after someone places his hand on his shoulder) as Private Baker of A Company. He may be right. But A Company had to fight its way to shore. The footage shows men walking rather casually on the beach, and at least one other Landing Craft Assault already ahead of the one carrying the camera—which strongly suggests C Company.

For the moment it is enough to know who these men are: they deserve that at least. It would be better still if those travelling to Normandy to honour their memory would drift away from the formal site of commemoration and take the time to visit the beaches at Bernières-sur-Mer where they came ashore. They will find no evidence of the landings along those quiet stretches. Sadly, at that place they will find nothing to mark the sacrifice of D-Day and nothing to mark the site of the iconic film footage of the greatest assault landing in the history of the world.


Email the writer at:

Email a letter to the editor at:

  • Pingback: How can I get the same weather forcast and news on the internet as television? | Watch TV on Internet Now()

  • Pingback: Groomsmen Gifts Are Testimonials To Valued Friendships | Home Weddings()

  • Pingback: World Series 2008 Phillies Champ Ryan Howard Homerun Practice | Art 188 News()

  • Pingback: Expo information: Tickets for May 1 sold out | Web Traffic Siphon()

  • Pingback: Saving Private Ryan (Blu-ray) | Our Pets()

  • Pingback: D-Day Footage - World War 2 Talk()

  • Pingback: Buy Targeted Fans()

  • Pingback: D-Day Footage - Page 3 - World War 2 Talk()

  • Pingback: D-Day Footage - World War 2 Talk()

  • Pingback: D-Day Footage - Page 5 - World War 2 Talk()

  • Tim Barron

    I have seen this footage numerous times and I have “heard” it also, my question is, “why is it always published without the soundtrack?”… I think I seen it during a documentary on the Canadian Film Unit, which I have been trying to find to purchase a copy. In it, you can hear bullet impacts on the hull of the landing craft, I would say “Higgins boat”, but I don’t believe it is…and you can hear and see the soldiers duck as the hits sound…. it adds so much more to the footage.

  • Stephen Hale

    I want to know the validity that all of the real footage was lost in transit. I’m having a hard time believing that. You always see the same ten or 15 seconds of the landings and yet, I know there were guys there recording it. Steve Hale, US Army Photographer, 1972-1977.

  • Stephen Hale

    If I’m wrong…it’s the biggest f*** up in Army history.

  • mookie

    The No 3 Film Unit had two sound units. The equipment was so large it required a CMP van to fit it all in and was so delicate it could be damaged by the sound of artillery fire, so was used strictly for interviews. The original footage was likely lost with all its documentation in the NFB fire of 1967. The most complete copy has six films from six LCAs that landed in Juno Sector. More films were likely taken, but may have been lost with the many LCAs that were sunk (HMCS Prince David lost all of her LCAs that day), or show scenes that were considered too disturbing and were censored. Best copy of these films I know of is at the US National Archives.

  • MichaelDorosh

    I attended a reunion in about 2004 of Italian Campaign veterans, where the guest of honour was Peter Stursberg. He explained that the sound recording equipment he used in Italy actually wrote information onto vinyl record discs. As you say, impractical for much more than interviews.

  • Michelle Finnegan

    Hello, Just reviewing this discussion and have something to add. My father was in “A” company and as stated above, landed at Bernières-sur-Mer and they fought their way to shore. In fact, my father described the landing of “A” company, completely different from this film clip. He told me that they were under heavy fire as they approached the beach…. their carrier had hung up on what they later believed was a sandbar….so that upon exiting, they were in about 10 feet of water. He used to jokingly say that he “walked” to the beach on the ocean floor as although he had lost his rifle, he still carried the rest of his equipment, which took him straight to the bottom. He said he retrieved a rifle from a dead soldier on the beach and kept going, men falling all around him. So, if his description is accurate, then the clip must be of “C” company.


Last Post


Classified Ads